Latest Movie News Headlines

Face-Off: Luke Skywalker vs. Harry Potter

11.15.2016by: Brian Bitner
In our previous Face-Off, I put 2015 boxing films SOUTHPAW and CREED into the ring. Most of you agreed with my decision to give it to the tale of Adonis Creed and Rocky Balboa, but there was plenty of love for SOUTHPAW as well, which was nice to see, as Antoine Fuqua breathed some much needed life into an otherwise stale genre.

This week, with FANTASTIC BEASTS AND WHERE TO FIND THEM hitting theaters this weekend and ROGUE ONE: A STAR WARS STORY landing next month, the HARRY POTTER and STAR WARS franchises continue to stand tall as two of the biggest intellectual properties around. What's interesting about both stories adhering so closely to Joseph Campbell's mythic hero is that you kind of end up with leads who are among the least interesting things in their respective stories. Don't get me wrong, we all love Luke Skywalker and Harry Potter, but neither of them tends to be very complicated, and we spend a lot of time feeling like they're just along for the ride- until they eventually learn how to be badasses and triumph over evil, that is. Anyway, enough exposition, let's make these whiny white kids fight.
ACTOR
Mark Hamill comes across as a whiny child in A NEW HOPE, which, while it's the intention of the character, still feels a bit over he top. That said, by RETURN OF THE JEDI, we see a fully transformed performance, in which we completely buy Hamill as a meditative badass.
Ah, the Potter kids. When the HARRY POTTER franchise started, we loved it in spite of the child performances. Granted, Daniel Radcliffe shows a considerable amount of growth by the final film, but he never quite reaches the point of a really impressive performance.
LOOK
In just three films, Luke has had several iconic outfits. He starts in pure farm boy whites and ends in jet black, Imperial-adjacent garb, with the classic rebel pilot suit, Dagobah training gear, and Endor recon uniform along the way.

Yes, there's also the old hermit on a hill getup, but his brief appearance in Episode VII barely counts as anything just yet.
Outfit-wise, Harry usually wears a school uniform and Gryffindor scarf, which is a good look but muted a bit by the fact everyone else wears it. Other than dressing up for the occasional ball or Quidditch match, we generally just see him in his uniform or street clothes. Where Harry does stand out, though, is the iconic look of his glasses and scar. The fact that you can draw a pair of glasses under a lightning bolt and have an instantly recognizable character is pretty impressive and worth a point here.
WEAPON
The lightsaber- maybe the most iconic weapon to ever originate in a film. Move along.
The films go into the importance of wands and Harry's own holly with phoenix feather core accessory, but wands are just too small to look impressive or show up well on the screen.
POWERS
Jedi mind trick, telekinesis, telepathy, focus, and communication with the Force- impressive, to be sure, and Luke certainly has access to more abilities that we see in the film, but especially in his refusal to use Dark Side powers, we only see these displayed.
Similarly, Harry Potter has access to every spell known to the wizarding world. Most of the spells we see him cast involve telekinesis and other manipulation of solid matter, though we also get things like casting a patronus and the creation of fire and light.
STORY
After losing his aunt and uncle, Luke Skywalker joins the rebellion against the evil Empire, destroys their super weapon, the Death Star. After discovering the menacing Darth Vader is his father and Princess Leia his sister, Luke must face Vader and the Emperor in an effort to eliminate the Dark Side.
Orphaned in his infancy, Harry Potter, the Boy Who Lived, learns he is a wizard at the age of eleven and is accepted into Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. When the dark Lord Voldemort returns from obscurity, Harry must survive his attacks, destroy pieces of his soul, and face him in a final battle.

Neither of these stories is groundbreaking, but the family connection between Luke and Vader (and to a lesser extent, Leia) is a huge part of what makes STAR WARS so special.
MENTORS
Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda- two of the most recognizable mentors in cinematic history. Obi-Wan only teaches Luke the basics, but Yoda takes him as far through Jedi training as possible before becoming one with the Force himself, providing some universal philosophies along the way.
Albus Dumbledore, Sirius Black, and several other teachers and guides, including Remus Lupin and Rubeus Hagrid. You might argue for Yoda and Obi-wan on this one, but I'll call it a tie based on how heavily the HARRY POTTER franchise focuses on Harry's continuing development and search for guidance.
QUOTES
"But I was going into Tosche Station to pick up some power converters!"

"If there's a bright center to the universe, you're on the planet that it's farthest from."

"There's nothing for me here now. I want to learn the ways of the Force and become a Jedi like my father."

"I'm Luke Skywalker. I'm here to rescue you!"

"I have a very bad feeling about this."

"I won't fail you. I'm not afraid."

"There's something not right here... I feel cold. Death."

"I can help them! I feel the Force!"

"You'll find I'm full of surprises."

"No. No! That's not true. That's impossible!"

"May the force be with you."

"You will take me to Jabba now."

"I'm taking Captain Solo and his friends. You can either profit by this or be destroyed. It's your choice. But I warn you not to underestimate my powers."

"There is good in him. I've felt it. He won't turn me over to the Emperor. I can save him. I can turn him back to the good side. I have to try."

"The Force runs strong in my family. My father has it. I have it. And... my sister has it. Yes. It's you, Leia."

"Never. I'll never turn to the Dark Side. You've failed, your highness. I am a Jedi, like my father before me."

"I will not fight you, father."

"Your thoughts betray you, Father. I feel the good in you, the conflict."

"Father... I won't leave you."
"I'm a what? I can't be a-a-a wizard. I mean, I'm just Harry, just Harry."

"Please, please. Anything but Slytherin, anything but Slytherin."

"Checkmate."

"I'll be in my bedroom, making no noise and pretending that I don't exist."

"Promise me something. Never try to save my life again."

"Why would I go looking for someone who wants to kill me?"

"He was their friend, and he betrayed them. He was their friend! I hope he finds me! Cause when he does, I'm gonna be ready. When he does, I'm gonna kill him!"

"I love magic."

"Hey, my eyes aren't glistening with the ghosts of my past!"

"Sorry, Professor, but I must not tell lies."

"You're the weak one. And you'll never know love or friendship. And I feel sorry for you."

"The prophecy said neither one can live while the other one survives. It means one of us is going to have to kill the other, in the end."

"Be brave, Professor. Be brave like my mother... Otherwise, you disgrace her. Otherwise, she died for nothing. Otherwise, the bowl will remain empty... forever."

"When have any of our plans ever actually worked? We plan, we get there, all hell breaks loose!"

"No one else is going to die. Not for me."

"The longer we stay here, the stronger he gets."

"I suppose I'll have to kill him before he finds me."

"I never wanted any of you to die for me."
LEGACY
STAR WARS has become something much bigger than the main saga, with books, games, and television series taking place over multiple locations and time periods. That said, with the main saga focusing on the Skywalker family and Luke returning to the screen in Episodes VII - IX, there's no doubt the character is still extremely integral to the franchise.
Harry Potter kinda has it easy with the whole franchise bearing his name. While the upcoming FANTASTIC BEASTS AND WHERE TO FIND THEM series takes place before Harry's time, the young wizard is still present in video games, a new play- Harry Potter and the Cursed Child- currently running on the West End, and other scattered media.
LUKE SKYWALKER
Well, there you have it. That's more ties than I usually like, but that also just shows how two vastly different worlds can be fronted by the same fairly simple archetype. That's not a negative, by the way; an everyman protagonist is exactly how we as an audience are ushered into these incredible new worlds, and Luke Skywalker and Harry Potter are two of the best vessels we could ask for. It'll be interesting to see what the state of these franchises is twenty years from now. While Luke and Harry will likely be ancient history by then, both characters will forever be remembered and celebrated as the eyes through which the world first discovered these two colossal franchises. Let me know your choice down below, and in the meantime, I'll leave you with this little gem:

Harry vs. Luke



Agree? Disagree? Which do you prefer?
POST YOUR CHOICE BELOW!

If you have a suggestion for a future Face-Off, let us know below or send me an email at brianbitner@joblo.com.

RECOMMENDED MOVIE NEWS

MORE FUN FROM AROUND THE WEB

Strikeback
Not registered? Sign-up!
Or

12:52AM on 11/16/2016
I just wanted to say that your choice for a Face-Off is quite hilarious for this round.
Next, I recommend: Jason Statham Transporter vs. Jason Statham Crank
lol
I just wanted to say that your choice for a Face-Off is quite hilarious for this round.
Next, I recommend: Jason Statham Transporter vs. Jason Statham Crank
lol
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
+1
10:17PM on 11/15/2016

Harry Potter for the win

Many of the Ties should go to Harry Potter.. Powers.. Luke scratches the surface with his powers by the time he calls him self a Jedi Knight. He's control of the force is quite minimal, where as Harry was quite the Wizzard by the end of his journey.
I believe the weapons should be a Tie, Light Sabre's are epic however Luke barley uses his or knows how to in his 3 films. Also i think a wand should have more credit seeing how it takes more to use, based on the users knowledge under
Many of the Ties should go to Harry Potter.. Powers.. Luke scratches the surface with his powers by the time he calls him self a Jedi Knight. He's control of the force is quite minimal, where as Harry was quite the Wizzard by the end of his journey.
I believe the weapons should be a Tie, Light Sabre's are epic however Luke barley uses his or knows how to in his 3 films. Also i think a wand should have more credit seeing how it takes more to use, based on the users knowledge under pressure, and same could be said for a light sabre. Hence the tie.

I think you went for the safe call picking Luke, but I'm sure I'm the minority here

As an Actor, I'm sorry Daniel is much better.. i was quite shocked when i saw this result..
Story shouldn't be a Tie, the story is about Harrys Journey, Star Wars not. Luke is in 3 films, Harry is in all 8.


Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
5:05PM on 11/15/2016
The one thing these franchises have been common for me is I only liked the first three they made in each franchise. Technically to Star Wars fans I like episodes four five and six but they were still made first. And if Harry Potter was a real Baller he would've banged Hermione. So if I have to pick a winner a pick Star Wars. Plus I liked the Ewoks on endor.
The one thing these franchises have been common for me is I only liked the first three they made in each franchise. Technically to Star Wars fans I like episodes four five and six but they were still made first. And if Harry Potter was a real Baller he would've banged Hermione. So if I have to pick a winner a pick Star Wars. Plus I liked the Ewoks on endor.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
3:13PM on 11/15/2016
I never got into Harry Potter so I can't really comment on Harry, to be fair. I think I saw the first 2 films, something in between and maybe part 2 of the finale films and zero desire for fantastic beasts.
That said, Luke Skywalker for me, as a Star Wars fan.
I never got into Harry Potter so I can't really comment on Harry, to be fair. I think I saw the first 2 films, something in between and maybe part 2 of the finale films and zero desire for fantastic beasts.
That said, Luke Skywalker for me, as a Star Wars fan.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
3:05PM on 11/15/2016
I hesitated to read this because I figured you'd pick Harry lol...Luke all the way :)
I hesitated to read this because I figured you'd pick Harry lol...Luke all the way :)
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
3:03PM on 11/15/2016

I grew up with STAR WARS so Luke's journey resonates with me more

That said, the Harry Potter films were well done, and improved as they went along. And both actors have made some brave choices in their careers, which I respect.
That said, the Harry Potter films were well done, and improved as they went along. And both actors have made some brave choices in their careers, which I respect.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
+0
12:12PM on 11/15/2016
The only way I consider LUKE to be better is when comparing powers and weapons. In each installment, he starts out as a different person: First a young dreamer, then a confident pilot, then a serious warrior. In EPISODE IV, he comes off as bland, partly because he's overshadowed by the other human heroes. In EPISODE V, he finally starts to get developed. HARRY is much more consistent and starts getting developed from the very beginning.

[Spoilers ahead]

Let's look at it from another
The only way I consider LUKE to be better is when comparing powers and weapons. In each installment, he starts out as a different person: First a young dreamer, then a confident pilot, then a serious warrior. In EPISODE IV, he comes off as bland, partly because he's overshadowed by the other human heroes. In EPISODE V, he finally starts to get developed. HARRY is much more consistent and starts getting developed from the very beginning.

[Spoilers ahead]

Let's look at it from another perspective. Since the STAR WARS prequels and FANTASTIC BEASTS take place in the past, LUKE and HARRY can't be the protagonists. LUKE could've been one in EPISODE VII, but he was relegated to a cameo. That proved that he's not essential to the overall story. Can you imagine any of the HARRY POTTER movies without HARRY?
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
4:34PM on 11/15/2016
I would say you are right to an extent, I would say the Star Wars films are more about the Skywalker Family than any one member of it. Just like with out Harry there is no Films, I think with out the Skywalker Family there is no star wars films.
I would say you are right to an extent, I would say the Star Wars films are more about the Skywalker Family than any one member of it. Just like with out Harry there is no Films, I think with out the Skywalker Family there is no star wars films.
11:09AM on 11/15/2016

Luke

harry is fuck all without his little wand and spells....luke doesnt need anything but his thoughts to fuck you up....too bad the csuckers at disney will underuse his abilities.
harry is fuck all without his little wand and spells....luke doesnt need anything but his thoughts to fuck you up....too bad the csuckers at disney will underuse his abilities.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
11:01AM on 11/15/2016

Luke

Definitely Luke.
Definitely Luke.
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
+0
10:50AM on 11/15/2016
While I get (I guess) why they would be comparable, I don't think this was a fair Face Off. Still, it was a good read.
I think Luke and Rey would've been better. Or Harry and Frodo.

Ps. I completely agree with this: "The leads are among the least interesting things in their respective stories" HAhah
While I get (I guess) why they would be comparable, I don't think this was a fair Face Off. Still, it was a good read.
I think Luke and Rey would've been better. Or Harry and Frodo.

Ps. I completely agree with this: "The leads are among the least interesting things in their respective stories" HAhah
Your Reply:



Please email me when someone replies to my comment
View All Comments

Latest Entertainment News Headlines


Top
Loading...

Featured Youtube Videos

Views and Counting

Movie Hottie Of The Week

More